Efficiency of acute public hospitals in the region of Murcia, Spain
Publication: Journal of Comparative Effectiveness Research
Abstract
Aim: To evaluate the level of efficiency of public acute hospitals situated in the region of Murcia (Spain). Materials & methods: Data from nine acute general hospitals of Murcia’s Health Service (SMS by its Spanish acronym) were analyzed over the 2012–2014 period. The data were extracted from the In-patient Health Establishment Statistics of the Ministry of Health, Social Services and Equality, from the National Health Service (SNS) portal and the SMS portal. To this end, the data envelopment analysis (DEA)-window method was used, since this extension of the basic DEA model allows to compare the efficiency of a small number of units over different years and analyze changes in efficiency over time. In addition, the model was complemented by smooth bootstrapping and a superefficiency analysis to improve the quality of the data interpretation. Four inputs were used (number of beds, number of operating rooms, personnel costs and operating costs), two undesirable outputs (average stay and rate of return) and three desirable outputs (weighted discharges, emergencies and surgical interventions). Results: The average level of inefficiency was 1.58% over the study period, with a good evolution between 2012 (3.53%) and 2014 (0.20%). This improvement was also reflected in the number of efficient hospitals that rose from two in 2012 to eight in 2014. Moreover, the slack levels detected were small. Conclusion: The management of the public hospitals analyzed was favorable, both regarding average level of efficiency and the number of hospitals qualified as efficient. However, the analysis revealed several ways to increase efficiency by reducing specific inputs and nondesirable outputs (mainly operating and personnel costs as well as average length of stay) while increasing desirable outputs (mostly the number of surgical interventions). To finish, specific policy measures are suggested to improve the performance of these hospitals.
Supplementary Material
File (suppl_file.docx)
- Download
- 62.19 KB
References
1.
Nuño-Solinís R. Desarrollo e implementación de la Estrategia de Cronicidad del País Vasco: lecciones aprendidas. Gac. Sanit. 30(S1), 106–110 (2016).
2.
Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad. Estadística de Gasto Sanitario Público 2016. Principales resultados, Secretaría General de Sanidad y Consumo, Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad (2018).
3.
León J, Palomar JA. Indicadores de los Hospitales Públicos. Región de Murcia 2016. Consejería de Salud, Murcia, Spain (2018).
4.
Jacobs R, Smith P, Street A. Measuring Efficiency in Health Care: Analytic Techniques and Health Policy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, (2006).
5.
Charnes A, Cooper WW, Rhodes E. Measuring the efficiency of decision-making units. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 2(6), 429–444 (1978).
6.
Cantor VJ, Poh KL. Integrated analysis of healthcare efficiency: a systematic review. J. Med. Syst. 42(8), (2018) (Epub ahead of print).
7.
Nunamaker TR. Measuring routine nursing service efficiency: a comparison of cost per patient day and data envelopment analysis models. Health Serv. Res. 18(2), 183–208 (1983).
8.
Sherman D. Hospital efficiency measurement and evaluation: empirical test of a new technique. Med. Care 22(10), 922–938 (1984).
9.
Hollingsworth B, Dawson P, Maniadakis N. Efficiency measurement of healthcare: a review of non-parametric methods and applications. Health Care Manag. Sci. 2(3), 161–172 (1999).
10.
Hollingsworth B. Non-parametric and parametric applications measuring efficiency in healthcare. Health Care Manag. Sci. 6(4), 203–218 (2003).
11.
Hollingsworth B. The measurement of efficiency and productivity of healthcare delivery. Health Econ. 17, 1107–1128, (2008).
12.
Worthington A. Frontier efficiency measurement in health care: a review of empirical techniques and selected applications. Med. Care Res. Rev. 61(2), 1–36 (2004).
13.
Ozcan A. Health care benchmarking and performance evaluation. An Assessment Using Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), (2nd Edition). Springer, Berlin, Germany (2014).
14.
O´Neill L, Rauner M, Hiedenberger K, Kraus M. A cross-national comparison and taxonomy of DEA-based hospital efficiency studies. Socio-Econ. Plan. Sci. 42, 158–189 (2008).
15.
Kohl S, Schoenfelder J, Fügener A, Brunner J. The use of data envelopment analysis (DEA) in healthcare on a focus on hospitals. Health Care Manag. Sci. (2018) (Epub ahead of print).
16.
Puig-Junoy J. Eficiencia en la atención primaria de salud: Una revisión crítica de las medidas de frontera. Rev. Esp. Salud Pública 74, 483–495 (2000).
17.
Giuffrida A, Gravelle H. Measuring performance in primary care: econometric analysis and DEA. Appl. Econ. 33, 163–175 (2001).
18.
Amado CAF, Dyson R. On comparing the performance of primary care providers. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 185, 915–932, (2008).
19.
Pelone F, Kringos DS, Romaniello A, Archibugi M, Salsiri C, Ricciardi W. Primary care efficiency measurement using data envelopment analysis: a systematic review. J. Med. Syst. 39(1), 1–14, (2015).
20.
Kontodinopoulos N, Niakas D. Efficiency measurement of hemodialysis units in Greece with data envelopment analysis. Health Policy 71, 195–204 (2005).
21.
Özgen H, Sahin I. Measurement of efficiency of the dialysis sector in Turkey using data envelopment analysis. Health Policy 95, 185–193 (2010).
22.
Katharaki G, Katharaki M, Katostaras T. An empirical study of comparing DEA and SFA methods to measure hospital units’ efficiency. IJOR 21(3), 341, (2014).
23.
Caballer-Tarazona M, Moya-Clemente I, Vivas-Consuelo D. A model to measure the efficiency of hospital performance. Math. Comput. Model 52, 1095–1102 (2010).
24.
Puig-Junoy J. Measuring health production performance in the OECD. Appl. Econ. Lett. 5(4), 255–259, (1998).
25.
Spinks J, Hollingsworth B. A cross-country comparison off technical efficiency of health production: a demonstration of pitfalls. Appl. Econ. 41, 417–427 (2009).
26.
Moran V, Jacobs R. An international comparison of efficiency of inpatient mental healthcare system. Health Policy 112, 88–99 (2013).
27.
Asandului L, Roman M, Fatulescu P. The efficiency of healthcare systems in Europe: a data envelopment analysis approach. Procedia Economics and Finance 10, 261–268 (2014) .
28.
Cheng G, Zervopoulos PD. Estimating the technical efficiency of healthcare systems: A cross-country comparison using the directional distance function. European Journal of Operational Research. Eur. J. of Opera. Res. 238(3), 899–910 (2014).
29.
Popescu C, Asandului L, Fatulescu P. A data envelopment analysis for evaluating Romania’s health system. Procedia. Soc. Behav. Sci. 109, 1185–1189 (2014).
30.
Varabyova Y, Müller JM. The efficiency of healthcare production in OECD countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis of cross-country comparisons. Health Policy 120(3), 252–263 (2016).
31.
Dervaux B, Ferrier GD, Leleu H, Valdmanis V. Comparing French and US hospital technologies: a directional input distance function approach. Appl. Econ. 36, 1065–1081 (2004).
32.
Steinmann I, Dittrich G, Karmann A, Zweifel P. Measuring and comparing the efficiency of German and Swiss hospitals. Eur. J. Health Econ. 5(3), 216–26 (2004).
33.
Linna M, Häkkinen U, Magnussen J. Comparing hospital cost efficiency between Norway and Finland. Health Policy 77, 268–278 (2006).
34.
Linna M, Häkkinen U, Peltola M et al. Measuring cost efficiency in the Nordic hospitals, a cross-sectional comparison of public hospitals in 2002. Health Care Manag. Sci. 13(4), 346–357 (2010).
35.
Medin E, Häkkinen U, Linna M, Anthun KS, Kittelsen SAC, Rehnberg C. International hospital productivity comparison: experiences from the Nordic countries. Health Policy 112, 80–87 (2013).
36.
Kittelsen EAC, Winsnes BA, Anthun KS et al. Descomposing the productivity differences between hospitals in the Nordic countries. J. Prod. Anal. 43, 281–293 (2015).
37.
Varabyova Y, Schreyögg J. International comparisons of the technical efficiency of the hospital sector: panel data analysis of OCDE countries using parametric and non-parametric approaches. Health Policy 112, 70–79 (2013).
38.
Mateus C, Joaquim I, Nunes C. Measuring hospital efficiency-comparing four European countries. Eur. J. Public Health 25(Suppl. 1), 52–58 (2015).
39.
Varabyova Y, Blankart CR, Torbika A, Schreyögg J. Comparing the efficiency of Hospitals in Italy and Germany: nonparametric conditional approach based on partial frontier. Health Care Manag. Sci. 20(3), 379–394, (2017).
40.
Cabello PA, Hidalgo A. Análisis de la eficiencia hospitalaria por Comunidad Autónoma en el ámbito del Sistema Nacional de Salud. Investigaciones Regionales 28, 147–158 (2014).
41.
Stefko R, Gavurova B, Kocisova K. Healthcare efficiency assessment using DEA analysis in the Slovak Republic. Health Econ. Rev. 8(1), 6 (2018).
42.
Cunha SC, Nunes AM. Techical efficiency of Portuguese public hospitals: a comparative analysis across the five regions of Portugal. Int. J. Health Plann. Mgmt. 34, e411–e422 (2019).
43.
Shain I, Ozcan YA. Public sector hospital efficiency for provincial markets in Turkey. J. Med. Syst. 24(6), 307–320 (2000).
44.
Sahin B, İlgün G. Assessment of the impact of public hospital associations (PHAs) on the efficiency of hospitals under the ministry of health in Turkey with data envelopment analysis. Health Care Manag. Sci. http://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-018-9463-5 (2018) (Epub ahead of print).
45.
Guo H, Zhao Y, Niu T, Tsui KL. Hong Kong hospital authority resourde efficiency evaluation: vis a novel DEA-Malmquist model and Tobit regression model. PLoS ONE 12(9), e0184211, (2017).
46.
Kruse FM, Stadhouders NW, Adang EM, Groenewoud S, Jeurissen PPT. Do private hospitals outperform public hospitals regarding efficiency, accessibility, and quality of care in the European Union? A literature review. Int. J. Health Plann. Mgmt. 33, e434–e453 (2018).
47.
Tiemann O, Schreyögg J, Busse R. Hospital ownership and efficiency: a review of studies with particular focus on Germany. Health Policy 104, 163–171 (2012).
48.
Alonso JM, Clifton J, Díaz-Fuentes D. The impact of new public management on efficiency: an analysis of Madrid´s hospitals. Health Policy 119(3), 333–340 (2015).
49.
Franco JL, Fullana C, Rúa A. Analysis of the technical efficiency of the forms of hospital management based on public-private collaboration of the Madrid Health Service, as compared with the traditional management. Int. J. Health Plann. Mgmt. 34, 414–442, https://doi.org/10.1002/hpm.2678 (2019).
50.
Franco JL, Fullana C. Los nuevos modelos de gestión hospitalaria como alternative para la sostenibilidad del sistema hospitalario público: un análisis de eficiencia en gasto sanitario. J. Healthc. Qual. Res. (2019) (Epub ahead of print).
51.
Gannon B. Testing for variation in technical efficiency of hospitals in Ireland. Econ. Soc. Rev. 36(3), 273–294 (2005).
52.
Chern JY, Wan TTH. The impact of the prospective payment system on the technical efficiency of hospitals. J. Med. Syst. 24(3), 159–172 (2000).
53.
Zhang X, Tone K, Lu Y. Impact of the local public hospital reform on the efficiency of medium-sized hospitals in Japan: an improved slacks-based measure data envelopment analysis approach. Health Serv. Res. 53(2), 896–918 (2018).
54.
Kazley AS, Ozcan YA. Electronic medical record use and efficiency: a DEA and windows analysis of hospitals. Socio-Econ. Plann. Sci. 43, 209–2016 (2009).
55.
Huerta TR, Thompson MA, Ford EW, Ford WF. Implementing electronic lab order entry management in hospitals: incremental strategies lead to better productivity outcomes. Int. J. Inf. Manage. 33, 40–47 (2013).
56.
Williams C, Asi Y, Raffenaud A, Bagwell M, Zeini I. The effect of information technology on hospital performance. Health Care Manag. Sci. 19, 338–346 (2016).
57.
Ley E. Eficiencia productiva: un estudio aplicado al sector hospitalario. Investig. Econ. 15(1), 71–88 (1991).
58.
Prior D. Technical efficiency and scope economies in hospitals. Appl. Econ. 28, 1295–1301 (1996).
59.
González López-Valcarcel B, Barber P. Changes in the efficiency of Spanish public hospitals after the introduction of program-contracts. Investig. Econ. 20(3), 377–402 (1996).
60.
Puig-Junoy J. Partitioning input cost efficiency into its allocative and technical components: an empirical DEA application to hospitals. Socio-Econ. Plann. Sci. 34, 199–218 (2000).
61.
Solà M, Prior D. Measuring productivity and quality changes using data envelopment analysis: an application to Catalan hospitals. Financ. Account. Manage. 17(3), 219–245, (2001).
62.
Herrero L, Martín JJ, López MP. Eficiencia técnica de los hospitales públicos y de las empresas públicas hospitalarias de Andalucía. Gac. Sanit. 29(4), 274–281 (2015).
63.
Campos MS, Fernández-Montes A, Gavilan JM, Velasco F. Public resource usage in health systems: a data envelopment analysis of the efficiency of health systems of autonomous communities in Spain. Public Health 138, 33–40 (2016).
64.
Carrillo M, Jorge JM. DEA-like efficiency ranking of regional health system in Spain. Soc. Indic. Res. 133(3), 1133–1149 (2017).
65.
Al-Amin M, Makarem SC, Rosko M. Efficiency and hospital effectiveness in improving hospital consumer assessment of healthcare providers and systems ratings. Health Care Manage. Rev. 41(4), 296–305 (2016).
66.
Giménez V, Prieto W, Prior D, Tortosa-Ausina E. Evaluation of efficiency in Colombian hospitals: an analysis for the post-reform period. Socio-Econ. Plan. Sci. 65, 20–35 (2019).
67.
Yildiz M, Heboyan V, Khan MM. Estimating technical efficiency of Turkish hospitals: implications for hospital reform initiatives. BMC Health Serv. Res. 18(1), 401 (2018).
68.
Valdmanis VG, Rosko MD, Mutter RL. Hospital quality, efficiency and input slack differentials. Health Serv. Res. 43(5p2), 1830–1848, (2008).
69.
Bilsel M, Davutyan N. Hospital efficiency with risk adjusted mortality as undesirable output: the Turkish case. Ann. Oper. Res. 221, 73–88 (2014).
70.
Büchner VA, Hinz V, Schreyögg J. Health systems: changes in hospital efficiency and profitability. Health Care Manag. Sci. 19, 130–143 (2016).
71.
Li Y, Lei X, Morton A. Performance evaluation of nonhomogeneous hospitals: the case of Hong Kong hospitals. Health Care Manage. Sci. (2018) (Epub ahead of print).
72.
Arocena P, García-Prado A. Accounting for quality in the measurement of hospital performance: evidence from Costa Rica. Health Econ. 16, 667–685 (2007).
73.
Ali M, Bebela M, Bamud T. Technical efficiency of selected hospitals in Eastern Ethiopia. Health Econ. Rev. 7(24), 1–13 (2017).
74.
Kounetas K, Papathanassopoulos F. How efficient are Greek hospitals? A case study using a double bootstrap approach. Eur. J. Health Econ. 14, 979–994 (2013).
75.
Zheng W, Sun H, Zhang P, Zhou G, Jin Q, Lu X. A four-stage DEA-based efficiency evaluation of public hospitals in China after the implementation of new medical reforms. PLoS ONE 13(10), e0203780, (2018).
76.
Cunha-Ferreira D, Morais-Nunes A, Cunha-Marques R. Doctors, nurses, and the optimal scale size in the Portuguese public hospitals. Health Policy 122, 1093–1100 (2018).
77.
Sultan WIM, Crispim J. Measuring the efficiency of Palestinian public hospitals during 2010-2015: an application of two-stage DEA method. BMC Health Serv. Res. 18(381), 1–17 (2018).
78.
Cooper WW, Seiford LM, Tone K. Data Envelopment Analysis: A Comprehensive Text with Models, Applications, References and DEA-Solver Software. Springer, NY, USA (2007).
79.
Charnes A, Cooper WW, Lewin AY, Seiford LM (Eds). Data Envelopment Analysis: Theory, Methodology and Applications, 2nd Edition. Kluwer Academic Publishers, NY, USA (1997).
80.
Charnes A, Cooper WW, Rhodes E. Evaluating program and managerial efficiency: an application of data envelopment analysis to program follow through. Manage. Sci. 27(6), 668–697 (1981).
81.
Norman M, Stoker B. DEA: The Assessment of Performance. John Wiley and Sons, 239, Chichester, UK, 239 (1991).
82.
Andersen P, Petersen NC. A procedure for ranking efficient units in DEA. Manage. Sci. 39(10), 1261–1264 (1993).
83.
Simar L, Wilson PW. Sensitivity analysis of efficiency scores: how to bootstrap in nonparametric frontier models. Manage. Sci. 44(1), 49–61 (1998).
84.
Löthgren M, Tambour M. Bootstrapping the data envelopment analysis Malmquist productivity index. Appl. Econ. 31, 417–425 (1999).
85.
Efron B. Bootstrap methods: another look at the jackknife. Ann. Stat. 7(1), 1–26 (1979).
86.
Tortosa-Ausina E, Grifell-Tatjé E, Armero C, Conesa D. Sensitivity analysis of efficiency and Malmquist productivity indices: an application to Spanish savings Banks. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 184, 1062–1084 (2008).
87.
Silverman BW. Density Estimation for Statistics and Data Analysis. Chapman and Hall, London, UK (1986).
88.
Simar L, Wilson PW. Statistical inference in nonparmetric frontier models: the state of the art. J. Prod. Anal. 13(1), 49–78 (2000).
89.
Newhouse JP. Frontier estimation: how useful a tool for health economics? J. Health Econ. 13(3), 317–322 (1994).
90.
Barros CP. Measuring efficiency in the hotel sector. Ann. Touris. Res. 32(2), 465–477 (2005).
91.
Fuentes R, Lillo-Bañuls A. Smoothed bootstrap Malmquist index based on DEA model to compute productivity of tax offices. Expert Syst. Appl. 42(5), 2442–2450 (2015).
92.
Bates L, Mukherjee JK, Santerre R. Market structure and technical efficiency in the hospital services industry: a DEA approach. Med. Care Res. Rev. 63(4), 499–524 (2006).
93.
Hailu A, Veeman TS. Non-parametric productivity analysis with undesirable outputs: an application to the Canadian pulp and paper industry. Am. J. Agr. Econ. 83(3), 605–616 (2001).
94.
Mandal S, Madheswaran S. Environmental efficiency of the Indian cement industry: an interstate analysis. Energy Policy 38(2), 1108–1118 (2010).
95.
Simar L, Wilson P. Non-parametric tests of returns to scale. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 139(1), 115–132 (2002).
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Pages: 929 - 946
PubMed: 31464149
Copyright
© 2019 Future Medicine Ltd.
History
Received: 26 December 2018
Accepted: 24 May 2019
Published online: 29 August 2019
Keywords:
Topics
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Article Usage
Article usage data only available from February 2023. Historical article usage data, showing the number of article downloads, is available upon request.
Citations
How to Cite
Efficiency of acute public hospitals in the region of Murcia, Spain. (2019) Journal of Comparative Effectiveness Research. DOI: 10.2217/cer-2018-0150
Export citation
Select the citation format you wish to export for this article or chapter.
Citing Literature
- Shengjiao Zhu, Jinsi Liu, Zhihua Wang, Shixiang Chen, Study on regional disparities and influencing factors of public health service supply in China from the perspective of fairness, BMC Health Services Research, 10.1186/s12913-025-13292-6, 25, 1, (2025).
- Anteneh Lamesgen, Belayneh Mengist, Elyas Melaku Mazengia, Bekalu Endalew, Level of technical efficiency and associated factors among health centers in East Gojjam Zone, Northwest Ethiopia: an application of the data envelopment analysis, BMC Health Services Research, 10.1186/s12913-024-10843-1, 24, 1, (2024).
- Dinesh R. Pai, Fatma Pakdil, Nasibeh Azadeh-Fard, Applications of data envelopment analysis in acute care hospitals: a systematic literature review, 1984–2022, Health Care Management Science, 10.1007/s10729-024-09669-4, 27, 2, (284-312), (2024).
- Nam Hyok Kim, Feng He, O Chol Kwon, Combining common-weights DEA window with the Malmquist index: A case of China’s iron and steel industry, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 10.1016/j.seps.2023.101596, 87, (101596), (2023).
- Wanmin Su, Liulin Du, Yujun Fan, Peixi Wang, Equity and efficiency of public hospitals’ health resource allocation in Guangdong Province, China, International Journal for Equity in Health, 10.1186/s12939-022-01741-1, 21, 1, (2022).
- Mohammed A. AlKhars, Ahmad H. Alnasser, Taqi AlFaraj, A Survey of DEA Window Analysis Applications, Processes, 10.3390/pr10091836, 10, 9, (1836), (2022).
- Pejman Peykani, Elaheh Memar-Masjed, Nasim Arabjazi, Mirpouya Mirmozaffari, Dynamic Performance Assessment of Hospitals by Applying Credibility-Based Fuzzy Window Data Envelopment Analysis, Healthcare, 10.3390/healthcare10050876, 10, 5, (876), (2022).
- Ivana Vaňková, Iveta Vrabková, Productivity analysis of regional-level hospital care in the Czech republic and Slovak Republic, BMC Health Services Research, 10.1186/s12913-022-07471-y, 22, 1, (2022).
- Pejman Peykani, Reza Farzipoor Saen, Fatemeh Sadat Seyed Esmaeili, Jafar Gheidar‐Kheljani, Window data envelopment analysis approach: A review and bibliometric analysis, Expert Systems, 10.1111/exsy.12721, 38, 7, (2021).
- Tao Liu, Jixia Li, Juan Chen, Shaolei Yang, Regional Differences and Influencing Factors of Allocation Efficiency of Rural Public Health Resources in China, Healthcare, 10.3390/healthcare8030270, 8, 3, (270), (2020).